• Current
• Archives
• Log In
• Register
• Announcements
• About JLT Articles
• For Authors

Home > Vol 14, No 2 (2020) > Werle

Dirk Werle und Uwe Maximilian Korn

Telling the Truth: Fictionality and Epic in Seventeenth-Century German Literature

(Abstract)

Full-length article in: JLT 14/2 (2020), 241–259.

Research on the history of fiction of the early modern period has up to now taken primarily the novel into consideration and paralleled the rise of the novel as the leading genre of narrative literature with the development of the modern consciousness of fictionality. In the present essay, we argue that contemporary reflections on fictionality in epic poetry, specifically, the carmen heroicum, must be taken into account to better understand the history of fiction from the seventeenth century onwards. The carmen heroicum, in the seventeenth century, is the leading narrative genre of contemporary poetics and as such often commented on in contexts involving questions of fictionality and the relationship between literature and truth, both in poetic treatises and in the poems themselves. To reconstruct a historical understanding of fictionality, the genre of the epic poem must therefore be taken into account.

The carmen heroicum was the central narrative genre in antiquity, in the sixteenth century in Italy and France, and still in the seventeenth century in Germany and England. Martin Opitz, in his ground-breaking poetic treatise, the Buch von der Deutschen Poeterey (1624), counts the carmen heroicum among the most important poetic genres; but for poetry written in German, he cites just one example of the genre, a text he wrote himself. The genre of the novel is not mentioned at all among the poetic genres in Opitz’ treatise. Many other German poetic treatises of the seventeenth century mention the importance of the carmen heroicum, but they, too, provide only few examples of the genre, even though there were many Latin and German-language epic poems in the long seventeenth century. For Opitz, a carmen heroicum has to be distinguished from a work of history insofar as its author is allowed to add fictional embellishments to the ›true core‹ of the poem. Nevertheless, the epic poet is, according to Opitz, still bound to the truthfulness of his narrative.

Shortly before the publication of Opitz’ book, Diederich von dem Werder translated Torquato Tasso’s epic poem Gerusalemme liberata (1580); his translation uses alexandrine verse, which had recently become widely successful in Germany, especially for epic poems. Von dem Werder exactly reproduces Tasso’s rhyming scheme and stanza form. He also supplies the text with several peritexts. In a preface, he assures the reader that, despite the description of unusual martial events and supernatural beings, his text can be considered poetry. In a historiographical introduction, he then describes the course of the First Crusade; however, he does not elaborate about the plot of the verse epic. In a preceding epyllion – also written in alexandrine verse – von dem Werder then poetically demonstrates how the poetry of a Christian poet differs from ancient models. All these efforts can be seen as parts of the attempt to legitimate the translation of fictional narrative in German poetry and poetics. Opitz and von dem Werder independently describe problems of contemporary literature in the 1620s using the example of the carmen heroicum. Both authors translate novels into German, too; but there are no poetological considerations in the prefaces of the novels that can be compared to those in the carmina heroica.

Poetics following the model established by Opitz develop genre systems in which the carmen heroicum is given an important place, too; for example, in Balthasar Kindermann’s Der Deutsche Poet (1664), Sigmund von Birken’s Teutsche Rede- bind- und Dicht-Kunst (1679), and Daniel Georg Morhof’s Unterricht von der Teutschen Sprache und Poesie (1682). Of particular interest for the history of fictionality is Albrecht Christian Rotth’s Vollständige Deutsche Poesie (1688). When elaborating on the carmen heroicum, Rotth gives the word ›fiction‹ a positive terminological value and he treats questions of fictionality extensively. Rotth combines two contradictory statements, namely that a carmen heroicum is a poem and therefore invented and that a carmen heroicum contains important truths and is therefore true. He further develops the idea of the ›truthful core‹ around which poetic inventions are laid. With an extended exegesis of Homer’s Odyssey, he then illustrates what it means precisely to separate the ›core‹ and the poetic embellishments in a poem. All these efforts can be seen as parts of the attempt to legitimize a poem that tells the truth in a fictional mode.

The paper argues that a history of fictionality must be a history that carefully reconstructs the various and specifically changing constellations of problems concerning how the phenomenon of fictionality may be interpreted in certain historical contexts. Relevant problems to which reflections on fictionality in seventeenth-century poetics of the epic poem and in paratexts to epic poems react are, on the one hand, the question of how the genre traditionally occupying the highest rank in genre taxonomy, the epic, can be adequately transformed in the German language, and, on the other hand, the question of how a poetic text can contain truths even if it is invented.

References

Birken, Siegmund von, Teutsche Rede- bind- und Dicht-Kunst [1679], Hildesheim/New York 1973.

Blumenberg, Hans, Wirklichkeitsbegriff und Möglichkeit des Romans, in: Hans Robert Jauß (ed.), Nachahmung und Illusion. Kolloquium Gießen Juni 1963. Vorlagen und Verhandlungen, München 1963, 9–27.

Ceresa, Bruno, Dietrichs von dem Werder deutsche Übersetzung von Tassos Gerusalemme liberata, Zürich 1973.

Conermann, Klaus (ed. in collaboration with Gabriele Ball/Andreas Herz), Briefe der Fruchtbringenden Gesellschaft und Beilagen. Die Zeit Fürst Ludwigs von Anhalt-Köthen 1617–1650, Vol. 4:1637–1638, Leipzig 2006.

Dünnhaupt, Gerhard, Nachwort des Herausgebers, in: Diederich von dem Werder, Gottfried von Bulljon, Oder Das Erlösete Jerusalem [1626], ed. by Gerhard Dünnhaupt, Tübingen 1974, 1–62.

Ernst, Ulrich, Lüge, integumentum und Fiktion in der antiken und mittelalterlichen Dichtungstheorie. Umrisse einer Poetik des Mendakischen, Das Mittelalter 9:2 (2004), 73–100.

Fludernik, Monika, The Fiction of the Rise of Fictionality, Poetics Today 93:1 (2018), 67–92.

Friedrich, Hans-Edwin, Fiktionalität im 18. Jahrhundert. Zur historischen Transformation eines literaturtheoretischen Konzepts, in: Simone Winko/Fotis Jannidis/Gerhard Lauer (ed.), Grenzen der Literatur. Zu Begriff und Phänomen des Literarischen, Berlin/New York 2009, 338–373.

Gallagher, Catherine, The Rise of Fictionality, in: Franco Moretti (ed.), The Novel, Vol. 1: History, Geography, and Culture, Princeton/Oxford 2006, 336–363.

Gittel, Benjamin, Fiktion und Genre. Systematische Überlegungen zu ihrem Verhältnis als Beitrag zur Historisierung und ›Kulturalisierung‹ von Fiktionalität, in: Johannes Franzen et al. (ed.), Geschichte der Fiktionalität. Diachrone Perspektiven auf ein kulturelles Konzept, Baden-Baden 2018, 19–49.

Haferland, Harald, Fiktionsvertrag und Fiktionsanzeigen, historisch betrachtet, Poetica 46 (2014), 41–83.

Kindermann, Balthasar, Der deutsche Poet [1664], Hildesheim/New York 1973.

Kleinschmidt, Erich, Die Wirklichkeit der Literatur. Fiktionsbewußtsein und das Problem der ästhetischen Realität von Dichtung in der Frühen Neuzeit, Deutsche Vierteljahrsschrift für Literaturwissenschaft und Geistesgeschichte 56 (1982), 174–197.

Köppe, Tilmann, Fiktionalität in der Neuzeit, in: Tilmann Köppe/Tobias Klauk (ed.), Fiktionalität. Ein interdisziplinäres Handbuch, Berlin/Boston 2014, 419–439.

Korn, Uwe Maximilian/Dirk Werle/Katharina Worms, Das carmen heroicum in der frühen Neuzeit. Zur Gattungsgeschichte epischer Versdichtungen im deutschen Kulturraum, Daphnis 46 (2018), 1–14.

Krüger, Reinhard, Zwischen Wunder und Wahrscheinlichkeit. Die Krise des französischen Versepos im 17. Jahrhundert, Marburg 1986.

Loredano, Giovanni Francesco, Dianea oder Rähtselgedicht, transl. by Diederich von dem Werder, ed. by Gerhard Dünnhaupt, Bern 1984.

Morhof, Daniel Georg, Unterricht von der Teutschen Sprache und Poesie [1682], ed. by Henning Boetius, Bad Homburg et al. 1969 [reprint of the edition Lübeck/Frankfurt a.M. 1700].

Müller-Bochat, Eberhard, Die Einheit des Wissens und das Epos. Zur Geschichte eines utopischen Gattungsbegriffs, Romanistisches Jahrbuch 17 (1966), 58–81.

Nelson, William, The Boundaries of Fiction in the Renaissance: A Treaty Between Truth and Falsehood, ELH 36:1 (1969), 30–58.

Opitz, Martin, Buch von der Deutschen Poeterey [1624], Studienausgabe, ed. by Herbert Jaumann, Stuttgart 2002.

Opitz, Martin, Briefwechsel und Lebenszeugnisse. Kritische Edition mit Übersetzung, ed. by Klaus Conermann, Berlin 2009.

Orlemanski, Julie, Who Has Fiction? Modernity, Fictionality, and the Middle Ages, New Literary History 50 (2019), 145–170.

Paige, Nicholas D., Before Fiction. The Ancien Régime of the Novel, Philadelphia 2011.

Paige, Nicholas D., Examples, Samples, Signs: An Artifactual View of Fictionality in the French Novel, 1681–1830, New Literary History 48 (2017), 503–530.

Rotth, Albrecht Christian, Vollständige Deutsche Poesie 1688, 2. Teilband, ed. by Rosmarie Zeller, Tübingen 2000.

Schottel, Justus Georg, Teutsche Vers- oder Reimkunst [1645], Hildesheim/New York 1976.

Stockhorst, Stefanie, Defining Conventions for the Verse Epic in German. Notes on the Relationship between Codified Poetics and Poetological Paratexts in the Baroque Poetry Reform, The Yale University Library Gazette 82:1/2 (2007), 39–53.

Stockhorst, Stefanie, Reformpoetik. Kodifizierte Genustheorie des Barock und alternative Normenbildung in poetologischen Paratexten, Tübingen 2008.

Trappen, Stefan, Fiktionsvorstellungen der Frühen Neuzeit. Über den Gegensatz zwischen »fabula« und »historia« und seine Bedeutung für die Poetik, Simpliciana 20 (1998), 137–163.

Von dem Werder, Diederich, Gottfried von Bulljon, Oder Das Erlösete Jerusalem. Erst von dem Hochberühmbten Poeten Torquato Tasso in Welscher Sprache beschrieben. Und nun in Deutsche Heroische Poesie Gesetzweise / als vormals nie mehr gesehen / uberbracht, Frankfurt a.M. 1626.

Wels, Volkhard, Der Begriff der Dichtung in der Frühen Neuzeit, Berlin/New York 2009.

Werle, Dirk, Von hohem Wesen. Zu Wahrheitsanspruch und Gattungspoetik epischer Versdichtungen im 17. Jahrhundert (am Beispiel von Caspar von Barth und Georg Greflinger), Zeitschrift für Germanistik. Neue Folge 28 (2018), 10–24.

Witkowski, Georg, Diederich von dem Werder. Ein Beitrag zur deutschen Literaturgeschichte des 17. Jahrhunderts, Leipzig 1887.

2021-07-02

JLTonline ISSN 1862-8990

Copyright © by the author. All rights reserved.
This work may be copied for non-profit educational use if proper credit is given to the author and JLTonline.
For other permission, please contact JLTonline.

Copyright © 2007 – present JLTonline

Contact Webmaster